Unrequited Law: Utah’s Century with the Seventeenth Amendment, 1913-2013
Abstract
This paper examines the role of the 17th Amendment, the provision that established the direct election of U.S. senators. It is important to first trace a history of the philosophical debate about the composition of the U.S. Senate in the context of republicanism, federalism, and later populist criticism. After examining the history of the Utah Legislature’s refusal to ratify the Amendment in 1913, this paper investigates the impact of the Amendment on the behavior of the new Senate. Such concentrated federal power has spurred the contemporary attempts of Utah lawmakers to reverse these perceived corruptions of the Constitution’s original intent. Ultimately, this paper argues that the century-long impact of the 17th Amendment has contributed to an ongoing crisis in modern American federalism and helps explain the synthesis of ideas which motivates current attempts to repeal and reform it.
Keywords
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
a) Authors retain copyright over their work, while allowing the conference to place this unpublished work under a Creative Commons Attribution License, which allows others to freely access, use, and share the work, with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and its initial presentation at this conference.
b) Authors are able to waive the terms of the CC license and enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution and subsequent publication of this work (e.g., publish a revised version in a journal, post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial presentation at this conference.
c) In addition, authors are encouraged to post and share their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) at any point before and after the conference.
d) The Author grants Marriott Library the nonexclusive, perpetual, worldwide, irrevocable right to reproduce, distribute, display, publish, archive, preserve, digitize, transcribe, translate, provide access and transmit their work (in whole or in part) for any non-commercial purpose including but not limited to archiving, academic research, and marketing in such tangible electronic formats as may be in existence now or hereafter developed.
e) Marriott Library may elect, in its sole discretion, not to exercise the rights granted herein.
f) Author shall retain copyright in and to the Work and Marriott Library shall provide proper attribution in its exercise of the rights granted herein.
g) Author is solely responsible and will indemnify and hold Marriott Library and/or the University of Utah harmless for any third party claims related to the Work as submitted for publication.
